Exclusive

'A choice between bad and worse': Igal Levin says U.S. is directly helping Russia and warns Ukraine

Nation

16 October, 12:16 PM

Israeli military analyst Igal Levin told Radio NV why he believes Ukraine should reject U.S. calls to halt strikes on Russian oil refineries and why European leaders have responded weakly to the crisis in U.S.-Ukraine relations on Oct. 16.

— Relations between the United States and Ukraine are in a deep crisis. U.S. President Donald Trump has once again returned to rhetoric portraying Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy as a dictator. On top of calling him a dictator, Trump has described him as "a comedian who had moderate success in the past." I remember you were concerned about this dictator rhetoric back in February 2025, when Trump first used that word. What do you think the consequences are now?

— Ukraine will continue striking Russian oil refineries, as Zelenskyy has said. We need to keep hitting as many targets as possible without listening to the Americans.

— President Zelenskyy gave an interview to the Financial Times in which he said, "The restrictions have been lifted. We've had enough." Donald Trump announced an energy ceasefire between Russia and Ukraine. Russia apparently knows nothing about it. Ukraine waited three days. Now we're seeing new results from attacks on Russia's oil industry. The main question everyone is grappling with, including Ukrainian officials, is what the consequences might be.

— The consequences will be bad. Ukraine faces either bad or very bad outcomes. Not striking the Russians would be very bad.

I hope Ukrainian officials understand that difficult times lie ahead.

Ukraine is fighting a terrible war against Russia, which is unwilling to give up its positions. The Russians have no intention of negotiating. Even if the conflict is frozen because of some very serious and irreversible negative developments inside Russia, the Russian state will survive. It will merely be a pause before the next war.

So the only thing officials should be concerned about is that things are going to get bad. That's it. You have to prepare for that.

— One of the key points President Zelenskyy has emphasized is the dangerous reduction in intelligence provided by the United States. There has been no complete suspension of intelligence sharing, but two incidents stand out: Kyiv was attacked with ballistic missiles on two consecutive nights, and both times the missiles struck before an air raid alert was issued. President Zelenskyy and Ukrainian Air Force spokesperson Yuriy Ihnat said that, for some reason, our U.S. partners had not shared information about the threat with us ...

— What do you mean, "for some reason"?

The Americans are helping the Russians. It's as simple as that: The Americans are helping the Russians. What should we do next? I'm telling you what comes next: Things will get bad. What's the point of [these discussions]? I don't understand.

It's very simple. Ukrainians are listening to us right now. We shouldn't treat them like idiots: The Americans are helping the Russians.

The U.S.-based Institute for the Study of War, which simply analyzes information and does not serve anyone's interests, says Ukraine has gained an opportunity to seize the strategic initiative this year. If that's the situation — the Russians cannot achieve their objectives on the battlefield, nothing is working for them, and their summer offensives have failed — and then America comes along and starts imposing restrictions in one area or another, that is direct assistance to the Russians.

We need to speak more plainly. Why beat around the bush? America is helping the Russians. That's it. What should Ukraine do? Keep striking, keep fighting. Will things continue to be bad? Yes, they will. It's all very clear.

— Can we say that Washington and Moscow are acting in coordination? In other words, does Moscow know that Washington will not warn Kyiv and then launch ballistic missile strikes? Can we assume they are coordinating their actions and have reached an agreement?

— Hold on a second. They called each other and reached an agreement — [Russian President Vladimir] Putin and Trump.

— They exchanged messages, spoke on the phone and gave a signal along the lines of: Tonight, we won't warn Kyiv that you're going to launch a ballistic missile strike.

— Yes, this is pressure on Ukraine. America is putting pressure on Ukraine.

— We have spoken many times on various broadcasts, and you have given examples of how the United States has helped Russia. There are indeed many such examples. The one thing we have never seen in modern history is a U.S. president so openly siding with the enemy. Consider the "diesel deal," other attempts to lift sanctions and a possible upcoming agreement to purchase Lukoil's foreign assets. How do you explain Trump's logic, given that he is facing enormous criticism at home over these actions, elections are approaching and his party's approval ratings are low?

— It's obvious that Trump is openly playing into Putin's hands. But let me remind you that hindsight is 20/20. There have indeed been hawkish U.S. presidents who viewed the confrontation with Russia through the lens of the fight against communism.

— The Red Scare.

— They were staunch anti-communists, extremely hard-line ones.

Henry Kissinger traveled to Moscow on direct orders from the U.S. president. It was the Cold War — seemingly a period of absolute hostility and confrontation. There was Vietnam, where people were shooting and killing each other. The Soviet Union supported North Vietnam, while America backed South Vietnam. And yet Kissinger flew to Moscow. He wasn't acting on his own initiative. He had been given a specific assignment.

Today, we're all so knowledgeable. We know about the Cuban Missile Crisis, and we know who was shot and who wasn't. But imagine yourself in that situation. Say you were a committed communist, and suddenly the leading advocate of capitalism and imperialism flew into the very heart of the cradle of the revolution.

If you read what left-wing terrorists wrote and examine their views, they were asking the same questions: "How could they come here? How could anyone talk to them? How could they reach an agreement? How could they withdraw their troops? How could they abandon us?"

People tend to see the world in black and white. They believe there are "good guys" and "bad guys." And when that worldview collapses, some even go as far as suicide. I'm talking about committed revolutionaries, for example.

The same thing happened on the other side. Entire countries were sacrificed. Take Rhodesia in Africa, for example. It was completely abandoned. Israel also found itself on the brink of being abandoned. It was saved almost at the last moment, when everything was hanging by a thread.

And Vietnam was abandoned. Do you know how they explained abandoning Vietnam? They blamed corruption, saying Vietnam was a corrupt country. They said the same thing about Afghanistan: corruption.

Some Trump supporters will say, "Corruption — why should we help corrupt people?" But do you know how much corruption there is in Saudi Arabia? Yet it is sold the best weapons in the world, which it uses with utter incompetence, if it uses them at all. Compared with Saudi Arabia, Ukrainians are models of absolute integrity. Everything in this world is relative.

I don't understand why people come up with these elaborate theories. One country has money, so others want to do business with it. Another doesn't have money. If Ukraine had a lot of money, plenty of countries would want to be its friends and help it, including the United States. If Ukraine had oil fields, for example.

It's all very simple.

You asked about the dictator issue. Yesterday, Trump was asked why he doesn't call Putin a dictator and a usurper. After all, Putin is effectively a dictator. Trump replied, "If I want to make a deal, I'm not going to insult him." That's logical. But he has insulted Zelenskyy.

Notice that Trump doesn't say Putin isn't a dictator. He says quite directly, "I want to make a deal, and I'm not going to insult the person I want to make a deal with."

That means he sees Putin as an equal. Two mafia bosses don't insult each other. They shake hands. They may plot against each other behind the scenes: Trump supplies weapons to Ukraine, while Putin supplies weapons to Iran. But they won't insult each other. They'll negotiate.

Their gangs may fight in the streets, kill each other and so on. But the bosses themselves, even if they have scores to settle, consider themselves equals and won't speak badly of each other.

Yet Trump called Zelenskyy a dictator. Zelenskyy is not a dictator at all. He was democratically elected. What does that tell us? It tells us that these relationships are unequal. Trump's attitude toward Zelenskyy is not the same as his attitude toward Putin.

So when people talk about the need to bring the parties to the negotiating table, they're not really talking about an agreement. They're talking about Ukraine's capitulation. The Americans want Ukraine to surrender.

But there are two problems. The first and most important is Ukrainian soldiers and citizens, who don't want that. The Americans get very irritated when Ukrainian troops go on the offensive and start winning on the battlefield. [That's why] they're now imposing even more restrictions on us and tying our hands. That's the first problem.

The second problem is the Europeans, particularly the British establishment. This isn't some conspiracy theory. Zelenskyy himself has spoken about it. He said that Ukraine managed to improve its relations with the Americans and Trump thanks to His Majesty King Charles III.

He said that openly. These aren't conspiracy theories or speculation. Zelenskyy clearly says the British crown is helping us and taking us under its wing.

It's all very simple. It couldn't be simpler. I've seen so many [theories]: elaborate schemes, bribing someone ... Good Lord, it's all very simple.

— I remember the bitter jokes in Ukraine after Donald Trump returned to the presidency. People said we should just wait until the United States started imposing sanctions directly on Ukraine. Now those bitter jokes seem increasingly close to becoming reality.

— Why call them jokes? I don't see anything funny about it. Could the Americans become Ukraine's enemies? Yes, they could. It's entirely possible. The world isn't black and white.

The United States is engaged in a global confrontation with China. If Washington is confronting China and wants to bet on Russia rather than Ukraine, then Ukraine will become its enemy.

Ukraine has Europe, and Europe is an American ally in three respects: civilizationally, as part of the West; militarily, through NATO; and strategically, in the confrontation with China.

That's why the Americans can't simply tell Europe to go to hell. If Europe turned its back on Ukraine, the United States would immediately walk away from the whole situation. Washington wanted to withdraw even before that.

The Americans are involved in these events largely because the Europeans support Ukraine — particularly Germany and the United Kingdom — not because the world is divided into light and darkness, with the Americans representing the light and standing on its side.

— It's also worth recalling that even Joe Biden, a president who took a much more pro-Ukrainian position, insisted that Ukraine should not strike Russian oil refineries. That's worth remembering in retrospect. Admittedly, at the time, Ukraine's defense forces didn't have the same capabilities. They didn't yet have the drones capable of carrying out such strikes. The issue was more about American weapons. So there was Biden, and now there's Trump.

— Ukraine already had those capabilities. They were more limited, but they existed. The restrictions concerned all strikes, not just those involving American weapons.

Ukraine had begun striking oil refineries but stopped because the Biden administration asked it to.

The Biden administration stopped Ukraine when it had routed Russian forces in late 2022. The Biden administration stopped Ukraine when Russian troops faced a catastrophic situation near Kherson.

Remember the whole story with the tanks? People have short memories. Everyone forgets.

The Germans finally agreed to provide tanks when the Americans did. Symbolically, the United States offered 20 Abrams tanks. Couldn't the Americans have supplied tanks? Of course they could. But they didn't. And how long did they delay the delivery of aircraft?

They were afraid of Ukraine.

Again, why invent explanations? Take Kissinger himself. He was 99 years old when, about six months before his death, in the spring of 2023, before Ukraine's counteroffensive failed, he said Ukraine should be admitted to NATO.

And he had previously opposed Ukraine's NATO membership. He explained why he had changed his mind: because such a powerful force should not be left without someone in control.

Kissinger was already very old. He didn't understand that a complicated strategy was unfolding: Instead of admitting Ukraine anywhere, they would simply cut it off from everything and tie its hands behind its back.

But why did he change his mind? Because Ukraine is strong. A country that powerful cannot be left to operate independently. It must be under NATO's control. And what does NATO's control mean? The United States.

Nobody in this world allows you to be strong. They will subjugate you so that you serve someone else's interests.

If a powerful state emerges and acts independently — and if it is genuinely powerful on its own — it could become your enemy tomorrow. If it remains independent.

Imagine a large, powerful country emerging in the world, one that is exceptionally skilled at warfare. And it isn't on your side, isn't part of your alliance, and you don't control its political elite.

Tomorrow, some conflict could arise, and that country might not be on your side. Who in their right mind would agree to that? Of course, nobody.

There are alternatives, such as simply preventing that country from becoming powerful in the first place. That's exactly what the Americans are doing.

Previously, they supplied weapons in small quantities, drop by drop, to weaken the Russians. At the cost of a few tens of billions of dollars, they effectively dismantled the Russian army.

But somewhere along the way, they went too far. Now they're throwing up their hands and saying, "What a disaster. We've driven Russia completely into China's arms."

They wanted to kill two birds with one stone. On the one hand, they wanted to prevent Ukraine from becoming a strong, independent state. On the other, they wanted to weaken Russia.

And they weakened Russia. After all, they don't need a strong Russia either.

The Americans only want countries that remain within their sphere of interests, in their hemisphere, and subordinate to them.

Those who refused to submit, such as Venezuela, were punished. Cuba was blockaded. People there have no electricity, no basic necessities, not even medicine. The situation is extremely difficult.

People simply don't talk much about Cuba, but there's a real disaster unfolding there. And a military invasion may even begin.

Those outside the American sphere of influence must also submit to Washington, whether South Korea, Taiwan, Japan or European countries.

The Americans can treat them with utter arrogance. Just remember the whole Greenland affair, for example.

Yet everything continues: Submarines are built, plans are developed, military exercises are conducted and American bases are established.

But ultimately, everything is subordinated to America and its interests.

What's more, why are the Europeans responding so weakly to what's happening now? Have you noticed how muted Europe's response has been?

— I think they're all working on a common policy.

— A common policy on how to respond to Washington right now. They don't fully understand how to deal with Washington. After all, they could ask, "Hello, what's going on?" But they're allies. There are contracts in place. American weapons are now arriving in Germany. Germany is rearming. These are major contracts.

It's as simple as that.

What should you do in a situation where you have to choose between bad and very bad? Choose bad. I hope Ukraine's leadership has the wisdom to choose bad rather than very bad.

Let me add an important point here. By "bad," I mean striking back. It's very good that Zelenskyy said Ukraine would continue its strikes. And, in fact, Ukraine has already struck the Ryazan oil refinery, so these aren't just empty words.

Ukraine's ability to carry out these [strikes] does not depend on Starlink in any way. But intelligence about Russian territory is another matter. Yes, that's bad, and it will get worse.

Golda Meir [the former Israeli prime minister] used to say that weakness is never forgiven. You must never appear weak.

I've heard defeatist voices in Ukraine saying we must not provoke Trump ahead of the elections. You cannot show weakness. Under no circumstances should you show weakness, or you'll be eaten alive. You have to strike.

If one of your hands is tied behind your back, you have to fight with the other. The world belongs only to those who fight and strike back.

When Israel faced the threat of American strikes and withdrew from the Sinai Peninsula, it continued building up its military. Later, it launched another offensive and recaptured the territory.

The only situation in which retreat might be justified is when there is an overwhelming imbalance of power — when the Americans say, "We're going to send our bombers into the air and level Kyiv." Yes, at that point, it's a dead end. There's no alternative. You have to accept their [terms].

But as long as we're talking only about restrictions on intelligence sharing ... Yes, this is war. In war, there are some really terrible situations when you have to operate with limited intelligence.

And that can happen not only because your partners are bastards and scumbags, but simply for technical reasons, if the enemy were fighting more intelligently than the Russians are.

Could the Russians fight more intelligently and less incompetently than they do now? Of course they could. And then things would be worse.

There's a concept known as the "fog of war." The fog of war describes a situation in which countless factors are at play and it's impossible to predict everything. One of those factors is that a partner may abandon you.

Allies betray each other. And in this case, we're not even talking about an ally. History is full of examples of allies betraying one another. Here, we're dealing with a country that isn't even an ally.

Should this be factored into Ukraine's strategy? Yes. When Ukrainian politicians and the General Staff develop their strategy, they must assume that the Americans could walk away at any moment.

After all, there are no binding commitments. Ukraine isn't receiving assistance simply because people like us or out of the goodness of their hearts.

So this possibility must be built into the strategy. That's why Ukraine must keep striking the Russians: burning their oil refineries and data centers.

Three of their data centers were damaged, and they're already howling. Ukraine should burn Sberbank's data centers to the ground and cut off all their ability to make bank transfers.

You must never show weakness.

Інші новини

Все новости