Europe

Lifting sanctions on Russian oligarchs creates dangerous precedent for EU — media

Nation

23 September, 01:13 PM

France sought the removal of EU sanctions on Russian billionaire Alisher Usmanov in exchange for hostages held in Baku, thus, creating a dangerous precedent, Yevropeiska Pravda reported on Sept. 23.

Baku reportedly promised Paris that it wш release several detained French nationals from prison if the EU cleared Usmanov from its sanctions registry. Among the high-profile prisoners held in Azerbaijan is French businessman Martin Ryan, who was arrested in Baku in December 2023 and sentenced on March 16, 2026, to ten years in prison on espionage charges that the French government has firmly rejected as politically motivated.

"If this scheme succeeds, it establishes a dangerous precedent: personal sanctions enacted specifically to counter Russian aggression against Ukraine will be transformed into political currency in disputes that have nothing to do with Ukraine, while hostage trading will become an accepted instrument for diluting international sanctions pressure," Yevropeiska Pravda warned.

The Luxembourg Precedent and the Cascade Effect

The push to delist Usmanov rapidly triggered secondary demands within the European bloc. Concurrently, the European Union removed Russian oligarch and Alfa Group co-founder Mikhail Fridman from the sanctions list following strong diplomatic intervention from Luxembourg.

When France, backed by Slovakia, began aggressively pushing for Usmanov's delisting in September 2026, Luxembourg’s ambassador warned European counterparts that if exemptions were granted for Usmanov, the Grand Duchy will insist on an identical concession for Fridman.

Luxembourg’s stance was driven by an active multi-billion-dollar legal battle: Fridman is now suing Luxembourg through international arbitration courts, demanding at least $16 billion in financial compensation for his frozen banking and corporate assets — litigation that has caused acute anxiety among Luxembourgish officials.

"Ultimately, the decisions on Fridman and Usmanov had to be negotiated as a single package. This episode highlights the acute danger of a domino effect once sanctions compliance begins to fray. The moment one capital secures a carve-out for a preferred oligarch, corporate lobbyists and special interests emerge across others," the analysis noted.

On Sept. 22, the Council of the European Union formally extended personal sanctions against individuals and corporate entities responsible for undermining Ukraine's sovereignty, independence, and territorial integrity for an additional 36 months, keeping measures in place through Sept. 22, 2029. However, the council officially excluded select prominent figures, including Fridman and Usmanov.

According to diplomatic reporting, while the initiative to remove the pair was spearheaded by Slovakia, France, and Luxembourg, the decisions were enacted unilaterally without prior coordination or consultation with the Ukrainian government.

Інші новини

Все новости